Skip to main content

Your Brand is Telling a Story—Is It the One You Want?

By Andrea
(Leadership)
Posted on 09/22/24
Share article

In the age of perpetual connectivity and information overload, a company’s brand is no longer a static entity or a neatly packaged set of logos and slogans. Whether you’re conscious of it or not, your brand is being built every day—by the decisions you make, the ones you don’t, and the perceptions of those who interact with your business. It’s a process that’s ongoing, evolving, and mainly out of your hands if you aren’t paying attention.

For some, this lack of control is a blind spot, a passive acceptance of the way things unfold. For others, it’s an opportunity to design something intentional, lasting, and unique. The difference between these two approaches—building a brand by default and building a brand by design—is vast. One leaves the narrative in the hands of others; the other deliberately crafts it, ensuring it speaks to the right audience, evokes the right emotions, and aligns with long-term goals.

But in a noisy marketplace where every company claims to stand for something, how do you know if your brand is drifting or being carefully steered?

“If you aren’t actively participating in the construction of your brand, rest assured, someone else is.”
Sunny Bonnell, Co-Founder & CEO, Motto®

The problem with branding by default

Let’s start with what happens when you aren’t deliberate about your brand. A brand by default is a brand that evolves haphazardly. Instead of being guided by a strong sense of purpose or a well-thought-out strategy, it’s subject to the whims of public perception, market trends, and whatever messaging is convenient at the time.

Perhaps your company launches a social media campaign responding to a trend, but that campaign doesn’t align with your larger identity. Or maybe your customer service team, lacking clear guidelines, handles issues differently from case to case, creating an inconsistent experience for your customers. Over time, this approach builds a brand narrative, but it’s one built on mixed signals, fragmented messaging, and reactive decisions.

For example, imagine a company that positions itself as eco-conscious but regularly partners with suppliers known for wasteful practices. Or a business that touts innovation but sticks to tried-and-true methods behind the scenes. Inconsistencies like these don’t go unnoticed. Customers pick up on them, and over time, they lose faith in the brand.

Branding by default allows others—consumers, competitors, even algorithms—to define your reputation. The danger here isn’t just in how the outside world perceives you, but in how you compromise the ability to tell your own story.

“A brand by design is one that has a clear sense of identity and expresses that identity consistently across all touchpoints.”
Ashleigh Hansberger, Co-Founder & Chief Strategy Officer, Motto®

The intentionality of branding by design

On the flip side is branding by design. This is the process of crafting a narrative that reflects the company’s values, vision, and purpose—not just at the outset, but in a way that adapts as the business grows and shifts. A brand built by design has a clear sense of identity and expresses that identity consistently across all touchpoints.

Building a brand by design starts with one fundamental question: What do you want to stand for? It’s a deceptively simple question but one that demands a precise answer. Brands with staying power don’t try to be everything to everyone. They hone in on one big idea, one unique value that distinguishes them from the noise, and they double down on that.

Take Patagonia, for example. Their brand is built around a singular focus on environmental activism. Everything they do, from how they source materials to their public stance on political issues, reinforces this core identity. They are not reactive; they are proactive, constantly defining what they stand for and backing it up with action.

So, how do you design a resilient, consistent, and memorable brand? Here are a few guiding principles:

  • Know your purpose: A purpose is at the core of every great brand. What does your company exist to do? More importantly, why should anyone care? If you’re unsure of your brand’s purpose, your customers will be, too.
  • Focus on one big idea: Brands that try to stand for too much inevitably end up standing for nothing. To avoid this, focus on owning a singular, powerful idea. Nike owns performance. Apple owns simplicity. What will your brand own?
  • Be consistent, but adaptable: A brand by design doesn’t mean rigid. It means consistent in its values and adaptable in its methods. As markets shift, your brand should evolve, but the core identity must remain intact.
  • Lead with vision, not consensus: Great brands are built with bold vision. Leaders who try to please everyone end up pleasing no one. A brand designed to last isn’t afraid to stand firm on its principles, even if that means alienating some audiences in the process.
“Great brands are built with bold vision. Leaders who try to please everyone end up pleasing no one.”
Ashleigh Hansberger, Co-Founder & Chief Strategy Officer, Motto®

The future of your brand depends on the choices you make today

At the heart of this discussion is the idea that brands are living things. They don’t stop growing or changing just because you aren’t paying attention. The world moves too fast, and consumer expectations shift too frequently, for any business to think it can sit back and let its brand run on autopilot.

If you aren’t actively participating in the construction of your brand, rest assured, someone else is. Whether it’s through online reviews, word-of-mouth recommendations, or fleeting impressions left by a forgettable website, the world is shaping your brand—sometimes in ways you may not like.

The alternative is to take control. To step up as the designer of your brand’s story, making thoughtful choices that reflect your values, speak to your audience, and create a lasting impact. A brand by design is one that is prepared for the future, not scrambling to keep up with it.

“A brand by design is prepared for the future, not scrambling to keep up with it.”
Ashleigh Hansberger, Co-Founder & Chief Strategy Officer, Motto®

Brand by design has staying power

It’s easy to think of branding as static—something you can set and forget. But the truth is, your brand is an ongoing story, a narrative that is constantly being written. The question is, are you the one writing it?

Brands built by default are at the mercy of external forces. Brands built by design are intentional, strategic, and positioned to thrive in the long term. Ultimately, it’s up to you: will your brand be shaped by chance or choice?

If you want to matter, you need to take the reins.

Andrea profile picture
By Andrea